The two
states which I have visited in the last few days
are Kerala and Gujarat. They are hundreds of
miles apart, but I saw something common between
the two. Kerala in the south is left of the
centre and Gujarat in western India is right of
the centre. Both are headed by persons who are
ideologically fundamentalists. Kerala Chief
Minister V.S. Achuthanandan is committed to
communism which has Stalin as its hero. Gujarat
is headed by Narendra Modi, a fundamentalist in
Hindutva drawing inspiration from the Rashtriya
Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).
Mahatma Gandhi, who won us independence, does
not figure in the ideology of both. Nor does his
picture hang in the politburos of the two. At
the Communist Party headquarters in Kolkata, you
can see the pictures of Marx and Engels. At the
RSS headquarters at Nagpur, the photos of
Shivaji and Maharana Pratap Singh are on
display, suggesting the militant side of Hindus.
Even when I have inquired the reason for the
absence of Gandhi’s portrait, they have simply
shrugged their shoulders as if he does not fit
into their scheme of things.
What l found most disturbing was the incipient
Islamic fundamentalism beginning to creep into
Kerala. Some 40 years ago, Gujarat had the first
Hindu Muslim riot. From then onwards the
Hindutva forces have kept on pushing through
propaganda and at times through communal riots
to be where they are. They have more or less
achieved their objective when the Gujaratis
themselves do not distinguish between Hindutva
and Indian nationalism.
The disturbing trend in Kerala can still be
stopped by liberal Muslims leader. Instead, the
money is sought from abroad—it is alleged that
Pakistan’s ISI is making large contributions—to
finance fundamentalists to help them buy the
best of properties at key places. The Left is
unhappy. They are the ones fighting against
fundamentalists, the BJP hardly figuring
anywhere.
Why I am expressing my horror is the manner in
which Gujarat has undergone a change. It was a
secular society before the communal riots in
1969. Today, it is the stronghold of Hindutva. I
am concerned that Kerala may also go the Gujarat
way and become home for Muslim fundamentalists.
The recent Deobandh fatwa against terrorism has
made the entire Indian Muslims community think.
However, the terrorists have brought back the
vocabulary like they are fighting against “idol
worshippers.” The Indian Muslims have preferred
to stay away from the debate which the
terrorists are trying to degenerate into an
anti-Hindu campaign.
India’s first Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru,
had said that fundamentalism among minorities
could be curbed. But if the majority community
were to take to fundamentalism, the country
would go fascist. India has, by and large,
followed his principles of secularism. But where
probably the nation has failed is in Gujarat,
which is behaving as if pluralism does not suit
the genius of India.
In this kind of atmosphere, institutions adjust
themselves to the wishes of the master. I saw
the fear of Modi all around. He has been
taunting the centre to take action against him
for the Gujarat carnage. The centre has been
found too timid to do so. Now he is blessing
action against writers who point out that things
have not returned to normalcy and that the state
remains divided on communal lines.
For example, political psychologist Ashish Nandy
wrote early this year that “Gujarati Muslims too
are ‘adjusting’ to their new station. Denied
justice and proper compensation, and as second
class citizens in their home state, they have to
depend on voluntary efforts and donor agencies.
The state’s refusal to supply relief has been
partly met by voluntary groups having
fundamentalist sympathies...” I experienced this
when I was at Ahmedabad early this week.
What Nandy has stated is the truth without any
embellishment or exaggeration. Things are in
fact worse. Still, the state has issued a
notification to grant permission to the police
to file a criminal case against him. The
notification said: “There is prima facie
evidence against the accused for his involvement
in the commission of offences under sections of
the IPC.”
This is a blatant attack on the freedom of
expression. How can a free press, an integral
part of a democratic society, exist if Modi is
so touchy about even the mention of the riots in
which 2,000 Muslims were killed? I am encouraged
to see that some 170 intellectuals, including
academics, writers, film makers, journalists and
activists, from all over the world have issued
a joint statement condemning the anti-democratic
forces “that claim to speak on behalf of Hindu
values sometimes and patriotism at other times,
especially in Gujarat, but who have little
understanding of either.”
The ball is now in the court of the Gujarati
middle class, whether living in the UK, the USA
or in India itself. They must speak out because
it is their name that is being dragged through
the mud and it is they who are being blamed for
changing their values to chauvinism and
narrow-minded obscurantism. At the same time,
they should ensure the rehabilitation of Muslims
who were ousted from their villages and not
being allowed to return.
I met many of them who want to go back to their
homes and who are willing to forget and forgive
if given a chance to restart their lives. Modi’s
party, the BJP, is busy devising strategies for
the next general election and coining slogans
for electioneering. Probably, the Gujarat
example goes down well in some Hindi-speaking
states. It’s a pity that the BJP has no
compassion when it comes to the Muslims. But I
don’t expect even a modicum of rethinking in a
party which has dreams of establishing a Hindu
rashtra and anointing Modi as the Prime Minister
after L.K. Advani.
I recall the example of Bhindranwale, a Sikh
fundamentalist, in Punjab. He could have been
dealt with otherwise and the marching of forces
into the Golden Temple was not justified. After
all, the place is the Sikhs’ Vatican. At that
time the Sikh community should have asserted
itself and blocked Bhindrawale from occupying
the space which belonged to the nation.
New Delhi’s failure to take on communal forces
has created in Gujarat an atmosphere where even
a person like Nandy cannot highlight the truth.
Mind you, it has taken 40 years for Gujarat to
be what it is today, a purely Hindutva haven.
This may happen in Kerala and Islamic
fundamentalists may clone Gujarat. New Delhi has
so far stood helpless in the case of Gujarat.
That is to be deplored. Would the centre remain
inactive in Kerala and other parts where
extremists use Modi as their role model for
propagating communalism?